Start a relational network
- Pick a stimulus from the library, or type a new one.
- Click the board to place it, then drag it where you want it.
- Give it a function, with its strength.
- Draw an arrow from one stimulus to another, then choose the relation.
Or open an example:
Library
Choose a stimulus, then click the board to place it. With the keyboard, press Enter on it and it is placed in the middle of the board.
Stimuli and their functions
No stimuli yet. Pick one from the library or type a new one.
Relations
How the board reasons
These are the rules the board follows. They are written out so you can check them, and disagree with them.
Trained relations
An arrow from A to B is a trained relation. It reads "given A, pick B". It holds in each context you set it for. In a context where it is off, it shuts down: it is shown faded, and it takes no part in what is derived or in any function.
A new relation, or a stimulus's first function, applies in every context. A change made later applies to the current context, unless you choose every context. A new context starts as a copy of the current one.
Mutual entailment
Each relation has an inverse, so A to B also gives B to A:
- same as gives same as; opposite to gives opposite to; different from gives different from
- more than gives less than, and less than gives more than
- before gives after, and after gives before
- contains gives part of, and part of gives contains
- if … then (causes) gives caused by
- a relation you name yourself gives nothing back, unless you name its inverse
Combinatorial entailment
Two relations that meet at a stimulus give a third: A to B and B to C give A to C.
- same as, then any relation, gives that relation; any relation, then same as, gives that relation
- opposite to, then opposite to, gives same as
- more than, then more than, gives more than; less than, then less than, gives less than
- before, then before, gives before; after, then after, gives after
- contains, then contains, gives contains; part of, then part of, gives part of
- causes, then causes, gives causes; caused by, then caused by, gives caused by
Any other pair does not fix a relation, so the board lists it as not derived and never guesses. Two examples: more than, then less than; and opposite to, then more than. If A is a debt of 10, B a credit of 10 and C a debt of 50, then A is opposite to B and B is more than C, and A is more than C. If C were a credit of 5 instead, A would be less than C. So nothing follows.
Every rule above holds whatever values the stimuli have. The board is tested on thousands of random boards built from values, and each relation it derives must be true of them all.
A relation that rests on one trained relation is mutual entailment. One that rests on two or more is combinatorial entailment. The route shown under "derived from" is the first one the board found.
Conflicts
A pair is a conflict only when it holds two relations that cannot both be true. The board shows both and does not choose; where one of them was trained, the trained one is kept. These are the pairs that cannot both hold:
- same as, with opposite to, different from, more than, less than, before, after, contains or part of
- more than with less than; before with after; contains with part of
Every other pair can hold together, because the two relations speak of different things: different from goes with every relation but same as; causes goes with before, and with caused by (a loop where each causes the other); contains goes with more than; opposite to goes with more than. A relation you add yourself never makes a conflict, because the board does not know what it means.
Transformation of function
A function travels from a stimulus that has its own function to another stimulus the board relates to it, by trained or derived relations. Its kind and its strength are worked out separately:
- The kind comes from same as and opposite to. Same as keeps the function as it is. Opposite to carries the opposite function: a reinforcer becomes a punisher and a punisher a reinforcer; neutral stays neutral; a function you added yourself has no opposite, so nothing is carried. With neither, the kind is kept.
- The strength comes from more than and less than. The board counts the "more than" steps on the longest chain between the two stimuli that runs one way (more than, or less than read backwards, with any same as between). If A is more than B and B is more than C, A takes C's function two steps stronger, and it is still two if you also draw A more than C. Each step the other way makes it one step weaker. Strong stays strong and weak stays weak.
- So, whatever order you draw the arrows in, a stimulus that is more than another takes the function at least one step stronger than it, unless strong or weak holds them both. A stimulus that is opposite to a punisher and also more than it takes a reinforcer, one step stronger. Experts may read that last combination differently.
- A route that changes direction, such as A more than B and B less than C, says nothing about A and C, so it carries nothing. Comparisons that run in a circle, such as A more than B, B more than C and C more than A, contradict each other, so nothing is carried by them, inside the circle or through it. Every other relation carries nothing either.
Strength: 1 is strong, 2 is moderate and 3 is weak, so one step stronger goes from weak to moderate, or from moderate to strong. Neutral has no strength.
When functions compete
- Neutral counts only when nothing else reaches the stimulus.
- The strongest function wins: strong beats moderate, and moderate beats weak.
- At equal strength, a stimulus's own function beats one that reached it through a relation.
- If different functions are still tied, the result is shown as mixed.
Large boards
A large board is worked out in the background, so the page keeps working. If there is too much to work out, the board stops, shows what it has worked out so far, and says so.
Keyboard
Shortcuts work while focus is on the board or in the Stimuli list. Arrow keys move a stimulus; Enter or Space selects it; F2 renames it; Delete removes what is selected; Ctrl+Z undoes and Ctrl+Y redoes.
Single-key shortcuts: R relates two selected stimuli, or starts drawing a relation; A draws relations; V selects; D shows or hides derived relations; F sets a function; + and − zoom; 0 fits the board; N goes to the new stimulus field. Switch them off if they get in the way, for example with speech input.
About
Verse Whiteboard is built for work in Relational Frame Theory: training, research and theory about derived relational responding, by behaviour analysts, therapists, teachers and researchers. It draws from the language of that field: mutual and combinatorial entailment, the transformation of stimulus function, and contextual control of relations and functions (Crel and Cfunc).
Current work in the field includes the Hyper-Dimensional, Multi-Level framework, a framework for analysing arbitrarily applicable relational responding across several dimensions, from Dermot Barnes-Holmes, Yvonne Barnes-Holmes and colleagues; and Relational Density Theory, from Jordan Belisle and colleagues. Both grow out of radical behaviorism and functional contextualism. The rules above are this board's own, simplified; they are not taken from either.
Boards stay in this browser. Nothing you place on a board is sent to Verse Realm's servers. Export a board to keep a copy or share it.
Boards are kept as they are, not encrypted, so anyone using this browser profile can open them. Name stimuli with codes, never with anything that identifies a client.